Chapter 1: Can we replace the tiles on our listed Colt Hill cottage with a cheaper modern tile?
What we find
Listed status means that the roof is part of what is protected, and the materials count as much as the shape. Cottages like those at Albert Cottages are likely to have handmade clay tile or natural slate in a specific colour and texture, and a machine-made substitute will look different from the road even if the colour is close. The council will usually ask why a material has to change, and a roof that is merely tired is not a good reason.
Most owners ask this question when they are quoted for a full strip and find the price steep. The underlying cause is often a handful of failed tiles, nail sickness along one slope, or a lead flashing at the chimney, none of which need a new covering at all.
What we fix
We start with a photographic survey of every slope, which shows which tiles are cracked, which are sound, and where the fixings have failed. Repair is usually possible: we take out only the damaged tiles, keep the good ones for reuse and match the replacements for colour, texture and thickness from reclaimed or handmade stock. New battens go in under the repaired area and tiles are fixed with stainless nails or clips. See our page on matching new tiles to an old roof for how matching works.
Where the survey shows that a bigger job is justified, we give you the photographs to take to the conservation officer before any materials are ordered. Single slate repairs are reported at £100 to £250 for labour in typical UK ranges, with scaffold extra, and the survey comes before any fixed quote.