Chapter 1: Can a clay tile roof on a listed Stockbridge building be repaired rather than replaced?
What we find
Old clay tiles are hand-made, slightly curved and uneven, and that unevenness gives a historic roof its character. They are hung on timber laths and often fixed with oak pegs or nails that have worn out over the years. Tiles that lose their hold slip out of line. Frost gets into the porous clay and flakes the face of the tile, so a roof can look fine from the pavement but crumble when someone handles a tile.
Sagging along a ridge or a gentle dip in a slope is not necessarily a fault, because timber frames move a little. What matters is whether the roof is keeping out the weather. On the main street of a town with Grade II* listed buildings, replacing the whole covering would also raise questions about consent that a repair avoids altogether.
What we fix
Repair is the first option here, and it is usually the right one. We photograph every slope and mark the tiles that have failed, then remove only those and keep every sound tile for reuse. Gaps are filled with reclaimed or hand-made clay tiles chosen for matching colour and camber. New battens go in beneath stripped sections and the tiles are re-fixed with modern fixings, so they stay put.
We give you the survey photographs and a written description to share with the conservation officer, which helps anyone who needs to approve a like-for-like repair. Where the underlay has perished, it can be replaced with breathable felt without changing the look of the roof. Reclaimed clay is priced by the tile, so the amount of work decides the cost. See pitched roofing for how these repairs run.