Chapter 1: Are the old clay tiles on our Godalming house worth repairing, or does the whole roof need replacing?
What we find
A plain clay tile roof, the kind the town centre appraisal describes on the older domestic buildings, can last a very long time because the tiles themselves rarely wear out. What fails is the way they are held. Many old tiles hang on iron nails or wooden pegs, and the nails corrode until the tiles slide out of position, which roofers call nail sickness. Frost also flakes the faces of softer tiles, and the battens underneath rot where water has got in.
From the garden you may see a wavy line along a course of tiles, odd gaps, or patches where newer tiles have been dropped in beside weathered ones. From the loft, daylight through the roof or darkened timber under the tiles tells you where water has been entering. The roof is rarely finished; it is usually tired in patches.
What we fix
We strip only the area that has failed, keep every sound tile, and match the gaps with reclaimed or handmade plain tiles chosen for colour and camber. New battens go under the stripped section, and the tiles are secured with fresh stainless nails or clips, never the old corroded ones. A listed building should have like-for-like work, and we photograph each stage so the council has a record of what was done.
If the underlay and battens have perished across most of a slope, repair stops making sense and a re-cover on new battens is the honest advice. The price range for a new roof on a semi or detached house is reported at £4,000 to £13,000 in typical UK guides. The fixed quote follows the survey. Our pitched roofing page sets out how these jobs run.